PALMOILMAGAZINE, JAKARTA – Friends of the Earth USA, WALHI (Friends of the Earth Indonesia), and Milieudefensie (Friends of the Earth Netherlands) have released a new report highlighting ongoing agrarian conflicts, governance failures, and lack of accountability in the operations of PT Astra Agro Lestari Tbk. (AAL) in Indonesia.
The report, titled “Memupuk Konflik: Bagaimana Astra Agro Lestari, Merek, dan Keuangan Besar Memanfaatkan Kesenjangan Tata Kelola di Indonesia,” reveals numerous environmental and governance violations committed by AAL. These include illegal palm oil plantations in forest areas, intimidation and criminal acts against environmental campaigners, and illegal operations by several AAL subsidiaries.
Key findings of the report include overlapping palm oil plantation concession areas in 17 AAL subsidiaries, covering 17,664 hectares of forest land in Indonesia, with 74% of these concession areas located in Sulawesi. Additionally, at least 1,100 hectares of AAL’s palm oil plantations were found to be illegal due to their development in forest areas, and three AAL subsidiaries in Sulawesi were operating without official business rights.
Also Read: Walhi and FoE Discover Six Weaknesses in Astra Agro Independent Report
The report also mentioned the consumers’ brands and agribusiness traders that got their supplies from AAL, and big capital owners that took advantages on the weak governance in Indonesia to run their operation.
To respond the findings, environment campaigner and stakeholders claimed to investigate and conduct close accountability. Manager of Forest and Plantation Campaign Walhi, Uli Arta Siagian emphasized it would need the authority in Indonesia so that AAL would return the people and smallholders’ areas. She also urged Ministry of Agrarian Affairs and Spatial should investigate the permits of AAL, confirm open access to the information.
“Land grabbing, human rights violation, and illegal operation in AAL should be the warn,” boru Siagian said, as in the official statement to Palmoilmagazine.com, Wednesday (26/6/2024).
The report was launched two years after federation of riends of the Earth firsty documented environment and human rights violation that AAL did. These triggered consumers’ brands and capital owners to review their business relationship with the company. Since 2022, some consumers’ brands postponed to purchase palm oil from the subsidiaries of AAL in certain capacity.
The supervision on AAL went viral to many countries. Since January 2024, European Union Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) would oblige the companies to show their free deforestation supply chain, respect international scale – human rights legal, and should have free prior informed consent (FPIC) approvement. If everything is not obeyed, there would be sanction significantly.
“The company could publish rhetoric commitment to emphasize human rights and realize environment sustainability but it would be enough to speak only. It needs accountability,” Senior Campaigner of Forest and Area, American Friends of the Earth, Gaurav Madan said.
Every campaigner emphasized it would be urgent to switch the cultivation in people’s base to stop deforestation and human rights violation with palm oil expansion in industrial scale. They guaranteed that the capital owners and palm oil buyers should stop their supports to monoculture plantation model that damaged the environment.
“To stop deforestation and human rights violation, we have to switch the forest cultivation in people – base. The capital owners and palm oil buyers should stop promoting palm oil industrial expansion,” Program Coordinator of International Forest at Milieudefensie (Friends of the Earth, Netherland), Danielle van Oijen said.
Danielle thought, to continue purchasing (palm oil products) from AAL would be risky for it has deforestation, illegal issues, and human rights violation risks. “The legal officers in European Union should investigate every transaction that involved AAL in a whole. This is about to confirm obedience to EUDR,” Danielle said. (T1)
